The Feedback Thread

Dimensions Magazine

Help Support Dimensions Magazine:

loopytheone

Staff member
Administrator
Global Moderator
Joined
Dec 14, 2012
Messages
4,375
Location
England
Following on from a topic on the main board, I decided to make a thread asking users for their feedback on issues regarding the forums. Here are some ideas for what you could tell us:

  • What you like
  • What you dislike
  • What you'd like to see introduced or done differently
Of course, you are welcome to give other types of feedback too, it is all appreciated. We want to try and keep the Dims community involved as much as possible as people are the life blood of the forum. However, just to clarify, we can't guarantee that we will be able to make every change suggested, but we will discuss them all and want to hear from you. :)
 

happily_married

Happy to be part of Dims!
Joined
Jul 14, 2012
Messages
1,658
Location
,
I like the chat idea too but honestly that’s only as good as the members online who actually want to chat. If only a few people (who actually want real time interaction) are online at any given time then chat won’t be successful. Hopefully enough people would be online together often enough to make it a successful option.
 

loopytheone

Staff member
Administrator
Global Moderator
Joined
Dec 14, 2012
Messages
4,375
Location
England
Honestly, the main issue with the chat idea is that it would need moderating 24/7 to keep out spambots etc and it's not something 3 volunteers could take on. I have been looking for ways around that though, to see if I can get something set up. No promises though.
 

happily_married

Happy to be part of Dims!
Joined
Jul 14, 2012
Messages
1,658
Location
,
That definitely makes the chat feature a tough problem to solve. If it can be done I think chat would be pretty popular.

I also wonder how practical it may be to put this sight up as a banner add on other websites. Those things work. I have a Fabarm shotgun now because of one of those. I had never even heard of Fabarm before seeing their add. I know that stuff costs money, but what if anyone here has a blog and they can put a link to dims up to draw attention? (I don’t have a blog, maybe I should start one?)

We have good topics here we just need more people weighing in on them. Getting people in the doors isn’t easy.
 

Unbasher

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
421
Location
Germany
First of all, I'm impressed and delighted by how much effort you put into continuously improving this site. Therefore I'll gladly give feedback:

- It would be terrific if one could filter stories, e.g. by length or theme. For instance, I'm only interested in BHM stories but not BBW and it takes a long time to read through them all.
- Perhaps one could auto-archive contributions older than x months/years and only display the more recent ones.
- On my profile page it's easy to see whom I follow but not my follwers. Could that be added? (Unless I've missed it; in that case please ignore.)
- I don't care too much for threads like „Which song is stuck in your head“ that can be found on any forum. I don't mind them, I just think they don't contribute to the purpose of this community.
- Some forums could be turned into one, e.g. the FA/FFA forum and the BHM/FFA forum.
 

loopytheone

Staff member
Administrator
Global Moderator
Joined
Dec 14, 2012
Messages
4,375
Location
England
I would really like to get a chat thing set up at some point, but I can't say either way whether it would be a viable idea or not, yet.

Hm, the banner idea is a good idea, HM, I'll bring that up with the site owner. I'm reminded of websites I used to go on in the early 2000s that often had free banners people could put on their website/blog for advertising, perhaps something like that would work? It's definitely trying to get people through the doors, as you put it, that is the challenge.

--

Unbasher, thanks for giving us feedback, it's great to hear especially from a new person! Can I ask, how did you find Dims?

The library has a sort of filter in the set up in the archives, so the BHM Story Board contains exclusively BHM stories. Only stories that are untouched for more than a year get sorted like that though, everything else gets put into the Recent Additions to attract attention to new stories/chapters. There's the old tagging system with BHM etc written in the titles, like you used, but it would be nice to have something to sort them automatically. I'm not sure how possible that is with the current board software, but I could certainly ask.

By contributions, do you mean general posts or stories specifically? We have something like that set up for stories (her name is agouderia and she moves stories to the right archives!) but we've been considering something similar for really old threads in general. Only, like, automatic, and not making agouderia run around trying to archive the whole site, coz that would be a bit mean of usl :p

Hm, what does your profile page look like when you view it? When I view mine, I can see the people I follow (circled in green below) and the people that follow me (circled in red) on the left side of the screen beneath my avatar. Does your look different to this?
dims followers.png

As for combining boards, that is something we are planning on doing. =) A lot of the boards have a certain history or significance that means they can't be combined though; to use your example, combining the BHM board and the FA/FFA board would leave the male FAs who aren't BHM (which is at least half of them!) nowhere to go to discuss their issues. It's difficult to balance combining boards with making sure everybody has a space where they feel at home.

Again, thanks for the suggestions, everyone! =)
 

Unbasher

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
421
Location
Germany
a) I found Dims by accident. I was working on a story and needed some information about a big-anatomy issue. One of the websites Google spat out led me to an archived story.
b) "By contributions, do you mean general posts or stories specifically?" Posts in general.
c) Whoops, my bad about the followers and followees. My page looks just like yours, only I was on the lookout for words, not images.
d) Also, my bad about combining the BHM and FA/FFA board.
 

happily_married

Happy to be part of Dims!
Joined
Jul 14, 2012
Messages
1,658
Location
,
@loopytheone mine looks like that but I use my phone and the people I follow/who follow me appear below my avatar and profile visitor messages. I haven’t used an actual laptop in ages and can’t log into Dims on my work computer.
 

newbiefa

Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2018
Messages
8
Location
, male
Hello! First time poster here. I hope to someday gather up the courage to properly introduce myself. But for now, my two cents:

Dead links. I'm a bit late to the site, and I find that whenever I'm browsing old threads, links no longer work. It's a real bummer, because there are such interesting topics and opinions, but dead links render some posts senseless :( There are many threads asking for old posts/stories/etc. I think this speaks for itself on how much this is needed!

Loving this site! Thanks for all the hard work!

edit: I mentioned before something about filtering search results, then found out it is already possible. :)
 

loopytheone

Staff member
Administrator
Global Moderator
Joined
Dec 14, 2012
Messages
4,375
Location
England
Hi Newbiefa, welcome to the board its great to have you! And thanks for the feedback too, its always great to hear from new members. =)

Yeah, we are trying to work on cleaning up the forums a bit. Dead links in themselves are always going to be an issue with a forum like this that goes back so many years, but we are doing our best to sort it.

Thanks again! =)
 

AmyJo1976

DM Supporter
Joined
Dec 7, 2011
Messages
2,470
Location
USA
I would really like to get a chat thing set up at some point, but I can't say either way whether it would be a viable idea or not, yet.

Hm, the banner idea is a good idea, HM, I'll bring that up with the site owner. I'm reminded of websites I used to go on in the early 2000s that often had free banners people could put on their website/blog for advertising, perhaps something like that would work? It's definitely trying to get people through the doors, as you put it, that is the challenge.

--

Unbasher, thanks for giving us feedback, it's great to hear especially from a new person! Can I ask, how did you find Dims?

The library has a sort of filter in the set up in the archives, so the BHM Story Board contains exclusively BHM stories. Only stories that are untouched for more than a year get sorted like that though, everything else gets put into the Recent Additions to attract attention to new stories/chapters. There's the old tagging system with BHM etc written in the titles, like you used, but it would be nice to have something to sort them automatically. I'm not sure how possible that is with the current board software, but I could certainly ask.

By contributions, do you mean general posts or stories specifically? We have something like that set up for stories (her name is agouderia and she moves stories to the right archives!) but we've been considering something similar for really old threads in general. Only, like, automatic, and not making agouderia run around trying to archive the whole site, coz that would be a bit mean of usl :p

Hm, what does your profile page look like when you view it? When I view mine, I can see the people I follow (circled in green below) and the people that follow me (circled in red) on the left side of the screen beneath my avatar. Does your look different to this?
View attachment 131670

As for combining boards, that is something we are planning on doing. =) A lot of the boards have a certain history or significance that means they can't be combined though; to use your example, combining the BHM board and the FA/FFA board would leave the male FAs who aren't BHM (which is at least half of them!) nowhere to go to discuss their issues. It's difficult to balance combining boards with making sure everybody has a space where they feel at home.

Again, thanks for the suggestions, everyone! =)
Just noticed that I'm forever captured in this nifty how-to. Probably the closest I'll ever get to being famous lol!
 

bubba350

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2007
Messages
53
Location
,
I am satisfied with the current boards. Open chat would be hard to moderate .
Other sites I frequent it often gets out of hand quickly. A set of rock solid rules would be needed and frequently reposted. The moderators would have to quick to delete offensive posts etc. Then there is the constant posting of spam or bot links and the trolls.
Now a days there seems to be just a lack of courtesy on differing views.
So many other social media outlets now a day, maybe some type advertising is appropriate.
Perhaps a slight change in the name. Which explains the fat positive outlook of the site.
Extra dimensions, XMl dimensions etc.
 

Emmy

something witty..
Joined
May 16, 2019
Messages
186
Location
by chicagoooooo
Following on from a topic on the main board, I decided to make a thread asking users for their feedback on issues regarding the forums. Here are some ideas for what you could tell us:

  • What you like
  • What you dislike
  • What you'd like to see introduced or done differently
Of course, you are welcome to give other types of feedback too, it is all appreciated. We want to try and keep the Dims community involved as much as possible as people are the life blood of the forum. However, just to clarify, we can't guarantee that we will be able to make every change suggested, but we will discuss them all and want to hear from you. :)
Screenshot_20190621-150403_Samsung Internet.jpg
 

Unbasher

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2018
Messages
421
Location
Germany
I have some feedback:


Would it be possible to show new posts immediately after you log in? Currently you have to click on a post to see recent other posts.
 

DragonFly

Ahem Prema
Staff member
Global Moderator
DM Supporter
Joined
Apr 28, 2017
Messages
1,888
Location
New York Hudson Valley
I have some feedback:


Would it be possible to show new posts immediately after you log in? Currently you have to click on a post to see recent other posts.
There is an option at the top if you choose new posts ( top blue bar) it will give you all new posts
 

Latest posts

Top