Title says it all, but here it is again; Who was your very first Plus-Sized Crush? For me it was no one I knew personally, but someone I grew up watching. Lori Beth Denberg : Most of you will probably remember her from "All That", a variety show on Nickelodeon. I watched that show religiously. Or you may remember her from a cameo appearance in "Dodgeball" toward the beginning of the movie, she is the plus sized cheerleader.